A few years back the BCCI took a step in the right direction in changing the format of Ranji Trophy matches. The induction of the two divisions (Elite and Plate) allowed the developing teams such as Rajasthan or Orissa who excel against the minor opponents to be given a chance against the high profile teams, such as Mumbai or Delhi. The format also meant a team which started off in 2nd division (Plate Division) could qualify and compete in the Elite division knockout stages. It was the right way to proceed to ensure the Ranji trophy stayed competitive. The time has come to take the next step and ensure that the schedule of the domestic tournaments prioritises four day cricket. The starting point is to have four day matches played throughout the whole season.
It is clear after the England tour debacle that the further focus needs to be on the 4-day games and less on ODI or twenty20. From a technical perspective, the selection process for the test team has also changed. At present, the selection criteria for a player for test cricket seem to be success in twenty20 or ODI format, rather than superlative performance in the 4-day Ranji trophy format. Suresh Raina or Yuvraj are perfect examples of players who are stars in the short format but have never cut it in the longer format. Apart from the hectic international schedule, the other reason players have disappointed in the longer format is because they haven’t played enough four day cricket. Similarly, bowlers are picked on performance of twenty20 or 50 over format. When was the last time Suresh Raina played a Ranji trophy match? Despite been fit since January, why hasn’t RP Singh played any 4-day format matches? The answer is that the way the domestic schedule is broken into dedicated windows for the different formats does not allow players a chance to play four day cricket.
Compare the Indian domestic schedule to the structure in England, South Africa and Australia. In England, the four day matches for Division 1 and Division 2 are played all the way from the start of April to the end of August. Throughout those 6 months the twenty20 also continues in parallel with four day county championships. Importantly, it means that, if an England player wants 4-day match practice, then there are matches scheduled throughout the season. Perfect examples of this scenario are Stuart Broad and Andrew Strauss. In between the India and Sri Lanka series, both players, were able to go back and get “match practice” before returning to the England team.
In Australia, the situation is similar to England with 4-day cricket played from the start of the cricket season in October all the way to the end – the first week of Match. The start of Big Bash this year has meant there is a gap of one month in between. This method is parallel to India’s in the way the IPL window is allocated.
The South Africa four day tournament starts from September and runs all the way into March. There is a dedicated window in November for ODI cricket (40over matches) and another three-week window in February for the twenty20 tournament.
Like India, the three countries mentioned above have a cricket season which lasts for about six months. The major difference being the four day practice matches are continuously played six months in England, five in Australia and four in South Africa. In India four day games are played only from November to December. Only teams in the top two of the respective groups in the elite league or top team in the plate league move on to the knockout competition in January. This means only six teams in India are playing 4-day cricket for three months. The schedule is further amusing as it caters for two months for ODI competition and then, of course, there is the window at end of season for IPL in May.
This brings us to the predicament that, if a test series is ongoing in India in early October or in February/ March, two times of the year when overseas teams normally do visit India, there are no domestic 4-day matches played across the country. How can a bowler or batsman get match practice during this time? How can a Gambhir or Ishant Sharma get match practice for 4-day matches if the player wants to prepare for a test match during that time?
It is part of the international schedule for India to host at least two ODI series between November and January. This means at least ten ODI during the time intervals. The batsman and bowlers who are in the ODI squad will miss the opportunity to play 4-day cricket during the specified time, so when is the next opportunity? The next available chance will be the Deodhar trophy played for two weeks from mid to late march. This is in strong contrast to the scheduling in the other three countries.
This presents a dilemma for players such as Suresh Raina or Yuvraj Singh. If India is scheduled to play ODI in November, December and January and a test series in February and March, then what options do Raina and Yuraj have to play 4-day matches in February or March? How can they practise to ensure their four day performances improve? Similarly, RP Singh cannot gain 4-day match practice after January?
Moreover, this system is further exposed for teams which appear in the Plate League Ranji trophy. For teams such as Jharkhand, Orissa or Hyderabad the four day matches are available only for two months. Unless the team qualifies for top position, the likes of Saurabh Tiwary playing for Jharkhand will only play a maximum of nine matches and a minimum of six. Compare this to Australia or England where a player will play a minimum of ten matches. As an example, if Saurabh Tiwary is away with the ODI team in December, the chances are he will only play a maximum of three or four matches. If the four day schedule was to be spread out, it would increase his options to play four day cricket, hence improve his four day skills.
The better approach would be the one followed in Australia and England. This means a four day match is followed by the one day match against the same opposition in the space of one week. For example, Mumbai will play Bengal in the Ranji trophy match and then after a couple of days play them in an ODI match. This format allows teams to play the four day cricket format over a longer period of time. This means all formats are played through the six months and players who need match practice in either format have the option available. It will also avoid the intense travel schedule for current domestic matches in which they try to cram seven 4-day matches into two months.
There is no doubt the interest in cricket has increased in India and the game has become widespread across the nation. The time has come to ensure all the formats are now played throughout the six months so the next generation is exposed to all formats.